Mattress

How To Choose A Mattress: Top 10 Things To Consider

Large grey mattress

A great night’s sleep starts with the right foundation, and that begins with your mattress. 

Whether you’re waking up with aches and pains or tossing and turning all night, your current bed could be the culprit. Choosing the right mattress isn’t just about comfort; it’s essential for your long-term health, spinal alignment, sleep quality, and even mood. 

With so many options on the market, deciding which mattress is right for you can be overwhelming. 

That’s why we’ve compiled the top 10 things to consider before buying a mattress. Let’s dive in!

Why Choosing the Right Mattress Matters

Your mattress plays a key role in your sleep quality, and by extension, your overall health. The right choice can lead to better nights and brighter days. 

Here’s why it’s so important:

  • Spinal Alignment: A supportive mattress keeps your spine in a neutral position, reducing back and neck pain.
  • Pressure Relief: Quality materials help distribute body weight evenly, minimizing stress on your joints and muscles.
  • Improved Sleep Quality: The right mattress reduces tossing and turning, helping you stay in deeper sleep stages longer.
  • Allergy Prevention: Hypoallergenic and breathable mattresses can reduce exposure to dust mites and allergens.
  • Mental and Physical Health: Consistent, restful sleep supports immune function, improves focus, and boosts mood.
  • Longevity and Value: A durable, well-made mattress lasts longer, saving you money in the long run.

Considering how much time you spend in bed, choosing the right mattress is one of the most important investments you can make in your health and comfort.

Inside padding is part of a decision making process for how to choose a mattress

10 Things To Consider When Buying A Mattress

So, how can you ensure you pick the perfect mattress for you? Well, everyone is different so here are a few things to consider. 

1. Sleeping Position

Everyone sleeps differently, and your mattress should support your preferred sleep style.

  • Back sleepers benefit from medium-firm mattresses that support spinal alignment without sacrificing comfort.
  • Side sleepers usually need a softer surface that cushions pressure points like the shoulders and hips.
  • Stomach sleepers require a firmer mattress to prevent their hips from sinking too far, which can strain the lower back.

Identifying your dominant sleep position helps narrow down the ideal firmness and materials for your needs.

 2. Mattress Type

Mattresses come in various types, and each offers a different feel and support level.

  • Memory Foam: Contours to your body and relieves pressure. Ideal for motion isolation and comfort.
  • Innerspring: Traditional, bouncy feel with strong support but less contouring. Great airflow for hot sleepers.
  • Hybrid: Combines coils and foam or latex, offering the best of both worlds.
  • Latex: Naturally breathable and responsive. Offers a bouncier, firmer feel and is eco-friendly.
Firmness level with inside padding part of how to choose a mattress

Understanding each type’s pros and cons helps you match the mattress to your lifestyle and preferences.

3. Firmness Level 

Firmness isn’t one-size-fits-all. 

  • Soft: Plush feel, great for lighter side sleepers.
  • Medium: Balanced support and comfort for most sleepers.
  • Firm: Solid support for stomach sleepers or those with back pain.

Firmness is subjective, so consider your weight and sleeping position to gauge what feels best.

4. Body Type & Weight

Your weight and height play a major role in mattress performance.

  • Lighter individuals often prefer softer mattresses that allow for proper sinkage.
  • Heavier individuals need firmer mattresses with robust support to avoid sagging.

Also, taller individuals might need longer or larger mattress sizes (like a California king) for full-body comfort.

5. Motion Isolation 

If you share a bed, motion isolation becomes a must. Memory foam and latex typically excel at reducing motion transfer, meaning you’re less likely to feel your partner’s tossing and turning. 

Couples with different sleep schedules or restless partners should look for mattresses that score high in motion absorption.

6. Temperature Regulation 

If you tend to sleep hot, choosing a cooling mattress is crucial. Cooling mattresses have cooling gel in their memory foam and quilting. 

Temperature regulation as part of how to choose a mattress

Temperature regulation is essential for uninterrupted sleep and keeps you from waking up in a sweat.

Pro Tip: Get a cooling pillow too!

7. Trial Period & Return Policy 

Even if a mattress sounds perfect on paper, you won’t know how it feels until you sleep on it.

Look for companies that offer at least a 90-night trial and hassle-free returns. 

This gives you time to truly test it out and make sure it’s the right fit for your body and sleep habits.

8. Warranty & Durability

A good mattress should last 7–10 years, and the warranty should reflect that. Look for a mattress warranty with clear terms regarding sagging, defects, and coverage.

High-quality materials that resist wear and tear, ensuring your investment holds up night after night, year after year.

9. Budget 

Mattresses range widely in price from budget-friendly models under $1,000 to luxury options over $10,000.

While it’s tempting to go for the cheapest option, remember: you’re investing in your health and daily well-being.

Consider the long-term benefits of quality sleep and find a mattress that balances cost, quality, and longevity. Strike a balance between a low-cost mattress that compromises on quality and a high-priced one that charges more for the brand than the value it delivers.

10. Customer Reviews & Ratings

Take the guesswork out by learning from others. Online reviews can give insight into comfort, firmness, customer service, durability, and potential red flags.

Look for detailed reviews from verified buyers, and pay attention to repeated themes, both positive and negative.

You can also look at industry awards from experts who rate them as the best mattress. 

Get The Perfect Mattress with Tampa Mattress Makers

At Tampa Mattress Makers, we know how personal mattress shopping can be. That’s why we take the time to help you explore all the options, from sleep positions and firmness levels to budget and body type, so you can find your perfect match.

Whether you’re shopping in-store or online, use this checklist to guide your decision. Don’t settle for a mattress that’s just “good enough.” Invest in your sleep, your comfort, and your future health with the right mattress.

Ready to upgrade your sleep? Visit Tampa Mattress Makers and let our experts help you rest easy.